Top News

The Taliban’s Letter to Malala Yousafzai

By

on

A senior Taliban commander on Wednesday published an open letter to Malala Yousafzai, in response to her speech at the United Nations on July 12, on the occasion of her 16th birthday.

The bizarre letter—in parts menacing, in parts almost apologetic—was written by Adnan Rasheed, a senior figure in the Pakistani Taliban who escaped in a prison break last year before vowing to assassinate former Pakistani president Pervez Musharraf.

In it, the militant jihadist quotes former secretary of State Henry Kissinger, the British philosopher Bertrand Russell, as well as a letter written by the British secretary of War in 1835 to make his case. It also includes a disclaimer: it does not express the official views of the Taliban or any other jihadi faction or group.

large_130717202648-pkg-malala-taliban-letter-morris-00000103-story-top

Miss Malala Yousafzai,

I am writing to you in my personal capacity this may not be the opinion or policy of Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan or other jihadi faction or group.

I heard about you through BBC Urdu service for the first time, when I was in bannu prison, at that time I wanted to write to you, to advise you to refrain from anti-Taliban activities you were involved in. but I could not find your address and I was thinking how to approach you with real or pseudo name, my all emotions were brotherly for you because we belong to same Yousafzai tribe. Meanwhile the prison brake happened and I was supposed to be in hiding. when you were attacked it was shocking for me I wished it would never happened and I had advised you before.

Taliban attacked you, was it islamically correct or wrong, or you were deserved to be killed or not, I will not go in this argument now, let’s we leave it to Allah All mighty, He is the best judge. Here I want to advise you as I am already late, I wish I would have advised u in my prison time and this accident would never happened. First of all please mind that Taliban never attacked you because of going to school or you were education lover, also please mind that Taliban or Mujahideen are not against the education of any men or women or girl. Taliban believe that you were intentionally writing against them and running a smearing campaign to malign their efforts to establish Islamic system in swat and your writings were provocative.

You have said in your speech yesterday that pen is mightier than sword, so they attacked you for your sword not for your books or school. There were thousands of girls who were going to school and college before and after the Taliban insurgency in swat, would you explain why were only you on their hit list???

Now to explain you the second point, why Taliban are blowing up schools? The answer to this questions in that not only Taliban in KPK or FATA are blowing up the schools but Pakistan Army and Frontier Constabulary is equally involved in this issue. The reason for this action is common between them that is turning of schools into hide outs and transit camps once it comes under control of either party Pakistan Army or Taliban.

In 2004 I was in Swat, I was researching on the causes of failure of the first revolution attempt by Sufi Muhammad. I came to know that FC was stationed in the schools of swat in tehsil Matta and FC was using schools as their transit camps and hid outs. Now tell me who to blame???

Dozens of schools and colleges are being used by Pakistan Army and FC as their barracks in FATA, you can find out easily if you like. So when something sacred is turned lethal it needs to be eliminated this is the policy of Taliban.

Blowing up schools when they are not using strategically is not the Taliban job, some black sheep of local administration may be involved to extract more and more funds in the name of schools to fill their bank accounts.

it was shocking for me I wished it would never happened

Now I come to the main point that is EDUCATION, it is amazing that you are Shouting for education, you and the UNO is pretending that as you were shot due to education, although this is not the reason, be honest, not the education but your propaganda was the issue and what you are doing now, you are using your tongue on the behest of the others and you must know that if the pen is mightier than the sword then tongue is sharper and the injury of sword can be hailed but the injury of the tongue never hails and in the wars tongue is more destructive than any weapon.

I would like to share with you that Indian sub-continent was highly educated and almost every citizen was able to read or write before British invasion. Locals used to teach British officers Arabic, Hindi, Urdu and Persian. Almost every mosque was acting as school too and Muslim emperors used to spend a huge sum of money on education. Muslim India was rich in farming, silk, and jute and from textile industry to ship building. No poverty, no crises and no clashes of civilization or religion. Because the education system was based on noble thoughts and noble curriculum.

I want to draw your attention to an extract from the minute written by Sir T.B Macaulay to British parliament dated 2nd February 1835 about what type of education system is required in Indian sub-continent to replace the Muslim education system. He stated “We must at present do our best to form a class who may be interpreters between us and the millions whom we govern, –a class of persons Indian in blood and color, but English in tastes, in opinions, in morals and in intellect” This was and this is the plan and mission of this so called education system for which you are ready to die, for which UNO takes you to their office to produce more and more Asians in blood but English in taste, to produce more and more Africans in color but English in opinion, to produce more and more non English people but English in morale. This so called education made Obama, the mass murder, your ideal. isn’t it?

Why they want to make all human beings English? because Englishmen are the staunch supporters and slaves of Jews. Do you know Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, the founder and symbol of English education in India was a freemasons.

You say a teacher, a pen and a book can change the world, yes I agree with, but which teacher which pen and which book? It is to be specified, Prophet Muhammad Peace be upon him said I am sent as a teacher, and the book He sent to teach is Quran. So a noble and pious teacher with prophetic curriculum can change the world not with satanic or secular curriculum.

You have given the example that once a journalist asked a student that why a talib afraid of this education he replied a talib didn’t know what was in this book. The same I say to you and through you to whole world that why they afraid from the book of Allah because they don’t know what is in it. Taliban want to implement what is in the book of ALLAH and UNO want to implement what they have in man-made books. We want to connect the world to their creator through the book of Allah and UNO want to enslave the world to few evil creatures.

You have talk about justice and equality from the stage of and unjust institution, the place where you were standing uttering for justice and equality, all the nations are not equal there, only five wicked states have the veto power and rest of them are powerless, dozens of time when all the world untied against the Israel only one veto was enough to press the throat of justice.

The place you were speaking to the world is heading towards new world order, I want to know what is wrong the old world order? They want to establish global education, global economy, global army, global trade, global government and finally global religion. I want to know is there any space for the prophetic guidance in all above global plans? Is there any space for Islamic sharia or Islamic law to which UN call inhumane and barbaric? You have talk about attack on polio team, would you explain why the then American foreign secretary of state Henry Kissinger, a Jew, said in 1973 to reduce the third world population by 80%. Why the sterilization and eugenics programs are running in different countries in one way or another under the umbrella of UNO. More than 1 million Muslim women have been sterilized in Uzbekistan forcibly without their consent. Bertrand Russell writes in his book the impact of science on society, “diet, injections and injunctions will combine, from a very early age, to produce the sort of character and sort of beliefs that the authorities consider desirable and any serious criticism of power that be will become psychologically impossible”. This is why we have the reservation on so called polio vaccination program.

You say Malala day is not your day it is the day of every person who has raised voice for their rights, I ask you why such a day in not assigned to Rachel Corrie, only because the  bulldozer was Israeli? Why such a day in not assigned to AffiaSiddique because the buyers are Americans? Why such day is not assigned to Faizan and Faheem because the killer was Raymond Davis? Why such a day in not assigned to those16 innocent afghan women and children who were shot dead by an American Robert Belas because he was not a talib. I ask you and be honest in reply, if you were shot but Americans in a drone attack, would world have ever heard updates on your medical status? Would you be called ‘daughter of the nation? Would the media make a fuss about you? Would General Kiyani have come to visit you and would the world media be constantly reporting on you? Would you were called to UN? Would a Malala day be announced?

More than 300 innocent women and children have been killed in drones attacks but who cares because attackers are highly educated, non-violent, peaceful Americans.

I wish, the compassion you learnt from Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him should be learnt by Pakistan Army so they could stop shedding of Muslim blood in FATA and Baluchistan. I wish, the compassion you learnt from Prophet Jesus should be learnt by USA and NATO so they should stop shedding blood of innocent Muslims across the world and I wish the same for followers of Buddha to stop killing of innocent unarmed Muslims in Burma, and Sri Lanka and wish the same for Indian army to follow Gandhi jee and stop genocide in Kashmir, And yes, The followers of bacha khan, the ANP has an example of non-violence in their five years regime in KPK province, for example Swat, where a single shot was not fired and we witnessed the followers of bacha khan implemented the philosophy of nonviolence in its true soul, with support of jets, tanks and gunships.

At the end I advise you to come back home, adopt the Islamic and pushtoon culture, join any female Islamic madrassa near your home town, study and learn the book of Allah, use your pen for Islam and plight of Muslim ummah and reveal the conspiracy of tiny elite who want to enslave the whole humanity for their evil agendas in the name of new world order.

All praises to Allah the creator of the Universe.

July 15, 2013. 

SOURCE:

http://www.thedailybeast.com/

Channel 4 News Confirms the Authenticity of this letter which happens to be genuine.

LETTER

Leave Comments

Comments

Recommended for you

  • pacelibero

    In India we don`t like the british but also we don`t like the muslims. I really wished all muslims leave india because they are destroying our land with their cow killing, terrorism, temple demolition and try to convert our hindu women to islam trough the dirty game of love jihad. India has great past because of our ancient hindu religion …Sanathan Dharma. Please muslims don`t try to credit yourself or the greatness of India before the british, during islamic moghul invasion India has suffered greatly. Ghandhi has made a great mistake to allow muslims to stay in India after liberating India from the british.

    • Amaan

      Shut up idiot. You cow lovers were nothing but ignorant before muslim rule. We tamed you to be humans. U were all lost in the caste system degrading the lower class. That is why many converted to Sikhs, Christians and Muslims. And there is no muslim terrorism, everything is fake created by your two faced selfish govt. Read the newspapers, ignorant being. And there is no demolition of temples, u destroyed babri masjid, and we muslims controlled our anger and were patient. You burned your women when their husbands died, we stopped that system, but sadly u still burn your daughter in laws in return for dowries.

      • http://dna.org/ DNA

        Please, both of you refrain from using offensive language.
        We should unite regardless of our religion, I don’t deny that there are religious sects that are evil, but that applies to every single major religion.

        • Amaan

          I agree and I am sorry, its just so sad that people come out n blame islam for everything .. when its just the 1% of the muslims that actually create trouble. But you are right, we have to unite as humans to overcome the evil in this world. Religion is never evil, its the people.

          • habib

            The problem is not the religion, it is the people who abuse it.

          • disqus_YMpqpHfEvM

            they are not muslims but munafiqeens

          • Robin

            You still made an angry rant about how hindus are subhumans, and now you are defensive for some reason. Don’t you want to apologize?

        • Puja Patel

          The God Delusion!

      • shubham joshi

        you blasphemous son of a bitch you should also not forget that fact that the entire idea of your religion was conceived only for the purpose of extending sexual pleasure to men…

        • Mohsin Ali

          absolutely wrong

        • sachin

          absolutely right

    • Romeo Khan

      Excuse me muslims are destroying india? lol Weekly Gang rape crimes are being done by hindus. you fucking lier. you idiot ignorant.
      and for kind information you idiots even didn’t know sew a dress, your
      men wore dhoti your women wore saarhi. we The Muslims Bring The greatest
      Civilization with our selves. Our cooking methods, construction, living
      style etc. you bloody cow piss drinker. your hindu era is the darkest
      era of indian history, your whole civilization is the worst brutal &
      darkest among all. where shoodar will be remain under the feet of the
      brahmans from birth to till death. your whole nation is based , built
      and standing on worst lies of history. bloody idiot

      • ayush

        and what about yr own religion which doesn’t even allow women to show there faces?which gives a man right to have 4 marriages at a time??go check the history from any source. islam has given the worst and most brutal dictators to the world. india was most prosperous country before your arrival & again will be after u all are gone

        • vijay muslim

          at least muslims are not liars, two-faced and back stabbers. they would have the same opinion face-to-face rather than change your words in the most clever way possible and act like a shallow human who honestly shouldn’t even exist.
          Rape central, people who worship stones crafted by some fat stinky village guy covered in fake jewels.. hue hue
          you indians (hindus) are the worst kind of human beings.. if we still count you guys under homo-sapiens.
          oh and 4 marriages so we don’t rape anyone we see.. and showing faces? get a life before writing bullcrap just to prove your point.. you just prove me right! ahaha
          all you guys are about running around trees and singing cheesy cheap songs which have no meaning what so ever… atleast thats what you people portray!
          so many muslims and just a few hindus left.. think where your loyalties should lie. about time this bullshit should be over..if not, we will continue to make fun of your hillarious backward and cheap lying nation.
          cheers:)

        • vijay muslim

          at least muslims are not liars, two-faced and back stabbers. they would have the same opinion face-to-face rather than change your words in the most clever way possible and act like a shallow human who honestly shouldn’t even exist.
          Rape central, people who worship stones crafted by some fat stinky village guy covered in fake jewels.. hue hue
          you indians (hindus) are the worst kind of human beings.. if we still count you guys under homo-sapiens.
          oh and 4 marriages so we don’t rape anyone we see.. and showing faces? get a life before writing bullcrap just to prove your point.. you just prove me right! ahaha
          all you guys are about running around trees and singing cheesy cheap songs which have no meaning what so ever… atleast thats what you people portray!
          so many muslims and just a few hindus left.. think where your loyalties should lie. about time this bullshit should be over..if not, we will continue to make fun of your hillarious backward and cheap lying nation.
          cheers:)

          • Puja Patel

            you hate Indians. Took all that effort to type complete trash. You seem narrow minded, biased and low on IQ brother, with a whole lot of time on your hands. The comment just REEKS of jealousy while genuinely making no sense.

          • citizen

            good thinking of yours….

          • Humza Tariq

            god you ignorant fucks are embarrasing. One side trash talks hindus and says islam is great. and vice versa. You all are ignorant. You especially. Stop trying to claim islam as your religion if youre going out of your way to attack someone wth your ignorant oppinions.

          • Robin

            So here we see the ignorant mudslinging again, ironically shown while trying to say other cultures suck.

        • Puja Patel

          right wing propaganda drilled into intellectually dull people.

        • shamroze

          it has nothing to do with islam .. what u mentioned it has to do with your lack of knowledge !
          In quran God first Orders man .. tht if u see any woman and any bad intentions come to your head ..U Must lower your gaze !! That means even if a girl is in mini skirt comes a man is ordered to look down ! GIVE RESPECT ! after tht women are ordered to cover their bodies.. and as a matter of fact there has to be a sheet like thing tht could cover a woman’s body she has to cover her head.. but she can let her face and hands up to the wrist be opened..and if tht is imposing and not giving value to a woman then why doesnt your hholy female gods are depicted in veil and all ?
          second.. only islam says u shud have one wife .. ur krishna has over or near 1000 wives..
          it says.. marry the woman of your choice in 2 3 4 BUT ! if u cant do justice to them equally then u shud marry only 1 ! does your religion has any obligations or limitations ?? read vedas and tell me if u do …
          if there is a widow or someone one who needs shelter rather than being a property for public.. its for themm.. its not for man’s pleasure and all.. coz if tht would be the case.. then every single muslim would be having 4 wives.. it is for the sake of woman’s security rather than man’s pleasure and lust as u think..!!

        • Guest

          The exact problem your men are facing is why in Islam you are allowed to marry more than one woman.. it’s made for societies like yours whose men can’t control their desires and act like animals rapping women everywhere.. it came to give dignity to animals like you… maybe if you practiced it there would be less rape in your country…

      • Abd’l Basit

        calm down bro… Werent we taught to respect other religions… peace bro

      • mskhickory

        valmiki the composer of ramayan is a shudra….if that helps. Knowledge is universal, just go read some – its free on .net

      • shubham joshi

        here’s something in the face of the entire islamic heritage http://www.kotiaho.net/swordoftruth/vpopia1.html

      • Humza Tariq

        Your english is awful. calm your tits.

      • #Psy

        This is the problem, you know. people like you guys are spreading hate amongst each other. I am a Hindu and have friends from all religions. I don’t see any difference between us except what and how we worship our gods. The discrimination is being injected in us by few people who have their selfish personal agendas and they use religion as a medium to divide. That’s what the British to India and that’s what some people from all religions (Islam, Hindu, Christianity…) are doing.

        If you read the holy books, the core message is the same but the interpretation different.

        Hating anyone because of his religion is insane. Every person is different and his deeds make him good or bad and not his religion. So guys, PEACE!

        • Mohsin Ali

          yeah! some people are good some are bad

      • Mohsin Ali

        if u will use offensive nobody will listen! be humble but firm

      • sachin

        4 out of 5 rapists in mumbai journalist rape were muslims.

    • Nomanshaheer

      Yes, I know how cultured were Hindu before arrival of Islam. They used to burn women alive with the death of their husbands but protected an animal Cow as God. This was the apex of Great Hindu Culture.

      • Puja Patel

        not true. burning women alive thrived under muslim kings in India as well. Both Hindus and Muslims, in India, tend to suppress women.

      • Robin

        Wow, you are quick to potty-mouth other religions while demanding respect for your own.

        Just… shut your ignorant mouth.

        • tolperon topedi

          Now I see how ignorant. Before the advent of Muslims, the porn temples like the kajuraho depicts the level of hindu insanity having sex with donkeys as engraved on the their so-called sacred walls.

          • Robin

            Is that what you have in reply? That some temple depicts sex with a donkey? Each religion has its insane and irrational parts and that includes islam especially.

            But do you know what’s really going on? They have a different view on sexuality than your culture, they are more liberated sexually and have temple celebrating it and not afraid to depict things from their mythology, even if immoral. Unlike you who have to label everything as shameful and evil and porn and dirty and something that must be avoided(Like labeling everything as shameful isn’t going to mess up a person hah). And your answer to other cultures is not to understand but to goose-step in and destroy what they have and make them good little slaves to what you believe in.

            But thanks again for proving further you have a potty-mouth. Using word like “Porn temple”, “Insanity” and “So.called sacred”. It proves further that letting other cultures exist is a horrible thing in your ignorant mind.

        • Mohsin Ali

          robin if you read class 9 ncert textbook you will come to know about sati system

          • Robin

            I don’t see why the practice of widow burning gives you the right to destroy religions and enforce much worse values on the people.

          • Mohsin Ali

            religion makes life easier it never makes life tough, tell me how sati makes life easier of women. u r degrading the values for women.

          • sachin

            What about you human bomb? why are you making fools of young boys of your faith by making them human bomb?

          • Mohsin Ali

            who is making human bombs? its not permissible in any religion in world, why you are relating this to Islamic faith.
            if a christian man steals something it does ‘nt mean that Christianity teaches stealing , it that the man is not following Christianity.
            99% of people are not following religion than why u r blaming religion?

          • sachin

            you can’t get away with the fact that these human bombs are influenced by the teachings of your clerics. and i don’t know why your clerics are brainwashing the young minds…

      • mskhickory

        did you know – the whole set of numerals, calculus were an Indian innovation. That your brothers from west copied books after books. You can wiki hindu numerals and see, If you are an indian – have you ever thought of what kind of knowledge did India generate in its history – have you ever taken pride in its real achievements, you accepting a god doesnt make a difference between you and me but your affiliation with some foreigners culturally doesnt make you indian any more. Gita, hindu numerals, astrology (“we knew of planets when the rest of the world thought world is flat”). Cow is revered as goddess becuase you take the milk and the whole of nutrition meant for its baby – a sacrifice from cow and if they are treated as gods – rightly so. Regarding sati, the custom was a protectionist mechanism from muslim invaders – unlike some of your forefathers who gave up at the cost of weapon and jaziya – some sacrificed and today you have sanathan dharm alive. go back and read your history. India produced people like Buddha and Jain. what the world is trying to achieve today (secular), India has done 2000 years ago. we believe god is one, you believe god is the only one…. India’s progress stopped after muslim invasion….that explains it all.

      • shubham joshi

        and perhaps you should also take note of the fact that muslims plundered our temples,burnt universities,forcibly converted buddhist and hindu monks…

        • Nawaz Khan

          80% of hindu population speaks volumes about the secular credentials of muslims and their tolerance towards other religions…during their invasion and 1000 years of governance…

        • Mohsin Ali

          this is the most funny thing which i have ever heard, this is not the truth, no one can convert anyone belief forcibly even modern science is not that advanced.

        • Robin

          Word. Muslims have inflicted horrible things on India but the derps keep saying they’re so super smart and tolerant and whatever other adjectives they like.

      • darth_vader

        That filthy culture started because the barbaric muslim rulers started raping and enslaving women who were alone. U misinformed pests are the ones this world should get rid off.

    • Nomanshaheer

      And By the way, Who is Gandhee to allow Muslims to live in India? We never required Gandhi Permission to live here. 70%-80% of Muslims were native Indians always who converted to Islam. So, India belonged to them as it belonged to others. Even if all Arabs, Afghan etc leave India, there may be 10%-20% reduction in Muslim Population in India. Because remaining 80% are Indian natives and conversion of a different religion does not snatch their right of living in their own country.

      • Puja Patel

        what are you talking about? In India, if you are a citizen then you are welcome to stay. You could be ruskin bond or even an ordinary columbian who has been staying in india for five years and applied for indian citizenship. Being born in India means you are a citizen which includes people of all origins. Persians, Syrians, Afgans etc.

    • Outspoken

      I’m a Hindu. @pacelibero:disqus acelibro, if you were a true Hindu you would not have
      spoken like this. Our religion in itself embraces Secularism. “Vasudeva
      Kudumbakam” which means “The world is one family”. Regardless of which
      means you choose to pray to your god, eventually we all pray to the
      mighty one. Hindus and Muslimss have lived in harmony for hundreds of
      years after the advent of Islam to India, both under Hindu and Muslim
      kings. The British sought to divide us for their own gains and we have
      been
      fighting ever since. The idea of India is the one of “pluralism”. When
      you have a theocratic state like Saudi Arabia or Pakistan, one becomes
      intolerant towards other minorities. We can’t afford to become like
      them. So please don’t you be the British in our modern day India!
      @To haters below: Please turn to reason and not abuse! It’s very easy to hurt souls instead of mending them.

      • D85

        @Outspoken Bravo. I pray to ALL that is holy, that more people embrace that which you speak.

      • Azwar Munir Goreja

        I SOLUTE U DEAR

      • godsinstrument

        Brother sanathana dharma its self is not a religion. the word it self describes the seculalirsm. Humanity is more important than any religion. we are humans first then the religion! It applies to any religion . Love all serve All. GOD Is no wer else its is
        You and I…man created religions trust me,

    • Puja Patel

      factually flawed. and i know plenty of cow eating hindus too.

      • vijay muslim

        good for you.. try to add them on facebook.. maybey you make some friends!

        • Puja Patel

          please try making sense of your posts. Go read some science.

          • Sushrut Badhe

            best not replying to peabrains- me thinks

        • BLACKSMITH

          Manusmriti even called for cattle sacrifices &how should it be consumed (yes to go deep it even spoke of human sacrifice).
          now leave that shit and stay on the topic. Which is regarding a letter

          • mskhickory

            we have long moved away from Manusmriti – half the indians dont even know the word. Valmiki and Vyasa both are from lower castes…by the way you can never compete at we are better than you. Bakrid – is real sacrifice of animals at mass level and at every home. You pick up some random events…there are atleast 20% hindus who are vegetarians….see the good side my friend.

          • Mohsin Ali

            see always good side and follow good things

    • Amer K

      before you take out the muslims, please take into account the dirty filthy indians who have committed the most vile acts of rape!

      • Robin

        Of course, but nobody should say hindus are devils and use the rape as an excuse to spout more hate.

    • suhail

      ..pacelibero…..oh stupid man….you are no longer to study…..do you know the majority in whole world is muslims , not hindus…….
      that is i don’t want to talk about these useless things but wanted to aware you….that hindu religion is nothing it is about only a mythology…….

      and where the matter of stragetic….then shut up all these useless advised and pay attention to your study with concept not by heart……

    • conflict

      lol

    • Tahani Hussein

      Burma is one of the many proofs of your terrorism … Just like the Jews you kill innocent men, women, and children in the most cruel inhuman way and you have the audacity to call us Muslims terrorist ? You should be honored to embrace Islam, it will clean your evil hearts. Look at what your men are doing to your women and you come to say that Muslims are destroying you? Your own kind/people/government destroys you not Muslims.. Your country is nothing without Muslims, they have been living there since ancient times they didn’t wait for Gandhi’s permission… part of your economic growth is due to the large Muslim population in India. Get your history straight before you come on here rambling about Muslims.

      • mskhickory

        i dont get you guys….do what you are doing to your self in pak, syria, afghanisthan, iran iraq etc. Killing yourself in hundreds of thousands. The fight in Burma is ethnic one like in srilanka – not islam vs buddhist and the numbers more meagre than any of the countries.

        • Shahzad

          Muslims in pakistan, india, syria, palestine, afghanisthan,burma, sri lanka etc. are brothers in islam, ONE UMMAH !!!!! Don’t forget, the Muslim Ummah is like one body. if the eye is in pain the whole body is in pain and if the head is in pain then the whole body is in pain. Don’t get tricked, these so called western drawn borders doesn’t split us !!!!!

          • mskhickory

            Nobody needs to split – humans think and operate individually. the fact is you and we all belong to different worlds with cultures much before islam existed – people are affiliated with the land they are from – you cant have one muslim as a better one because of his interpretation vs another one….each place and people are different and their languages are different. Thats the reality – at the outset you might say we are all united and one but you are not….why would you need to have so many countries even at the locations where you are 100%. How the saudis see and treat Indian muslims is so diffferent! the sameway how we treat them, Its better you start appreciating people are different and their belief system varies from place to place and there is nothing called perfect mohammedan or hindu or christian….you cant have a rule book of 6th century and say it applies for ever. Even if you say its does, even talibans in afghanisthan practically dont stick with it.

          • mskhickory

            Being under a Kind or Dictator is slavery. If those morons use religion to take control of our lives as individuals – the easiest weapon they can use is religion – allow that to happen, you are no more a human.

    • Faseeh M A Rahman

      we all love to live in peace……But there are others who dont want others to live in peace.They work for their own gain and not considering others.
      I donot recommend blindly believing the media because most of the things are being changed.
      I can also say that America has interfered with the affairs of almost all countries.
      Since i am a muslim i can strongly say that the word ISLAM means PEACE.
      Our prophet taught us to respect other religion too…… But most of the people interpret according to their views…..
      And for the history of India,,,,,our great grandfathers were freedom fighters…..their blood is in our body too….. because of our grandfathers who worked together without considering religion was the success to win the freedom that we r enjoying right now. If they were not in unity when they will get time to fight against british???

    • mskhickory

      i am big time supporter of Hindutva, RSS and BJP – your argument is so pathetic. I think people like you understand things incomplete and bring us all bad name. You cannot change history. Muslims/islam and christians are no different to many babas and gods we have in India and their followers. They are humans first and at the same time none of these things – air, water, land, minerals belong to you and me – they are gods wealth for sharing. When we say Akhand Bharat we dont think of kicking out muslims or christians, we just say any and all religions and faith can coexist – they are free to seek the truth. partition is wrong then and is wrong now.

      • BLACKSMITH

        lies. The saffron wing of Idia (hindu right wing) has been working against many religions and using newspapers, websites &medias to mock everything that is non-hindu. They also spread anti-secular messages and ask for purity of race. well known for creating violence, be it big riots or attack on newspapers &news channel offices. Check for the parallel works of hinduraashtra websites to know the truth. Neo-fascists. Fundamentalists. Ignorants
        In smple words, your knowledge about the group you belong to is incomplete. As far speaking of everyone being equal, i am glad atleast you realise that, unlike most from your group.

        • mskhickory

          get out of the victimhood mindset. you are better than that. Abuse is a reality in every religion, culture and in every part of world. Not just muslims, not just hindus or buddhists or christians. I belong to India, any indian any day is closer to me rather than someone 7 lands across and my faith is my personal and it has nothing to do with you or for that matter even my dad – I only share the gods wealth with you and not beliefs. On a second note – if muslims or anyone for that matter really think themselves as religion first and Indians next – then they would not have stayed here. Their affiliation to the land and family is bigger. They are here because they are first indians and then religion. Yes – I dont know everything about Hinduism or India or the whole science for that matter – hindutva is not a religion – its how you live – check out muslim marriages even today or how they greet their elders, the basic human instincts are same….Probably you should read first – give each other a chance, read and then comment rather than making assumptions.

          • BLACKSMITH

            I am not holding the mentality of vitvimhood. Perhaps you are really unaware of what saffron wing has been doing, if you wish to be ignorant-supporter , then you are no different the writer of this letter who tried putting it suvh a way that people might believe he is right, until you realise, that he mentions “Secular” education as satanic, the education he means is basically about his own religion irrespective of what truth or rationality is. You with-hold the same mentality, Before you advise me anymore, Do a researchwork, what are the “media” published by the saffron wings, and yes, take time to read them yourself.
            End of the matter. Stick to the topic. It is about a letter.

          • mskhickory

            I am part of the saffron brigade, if you believe that I can kill a Human – I dont believe in even killing an animal. Just that I talk, deal and negotiate openly – its a debate. I have no will to force things up on you. Since you are lazy to even google or get information, Just a recap – RSS or Hindu Mahasabha was born in 1928 primarily against the idea of creating 2 nations. The RSS was mostly strong intially in the then western part of India – especially in Muslim majority. Their primary concern being driven of the land they belong. Were there concerns wrong? Today less then 2% population live in those parts and less than 10% in bangladesh – as of 1948 they were 22%. where did this population go or runaway – your brothers there created a fear and did not allow practice of faith – whats happening today is they are fighting in between themselves about who is a better muslim and killing themselves every day.

            Had you guys even understood RSS idealogy (there are many learned muslims within RSS) – Akhand Bharat – your religion/belief is personal and and can seek truth different ways and that your faith has nothing todo with govt, knowledge is universal, and that you are just a caretaker of wealth and that you dont own any of it. You take the words of low rung leadership without know what it stand for.

            If the issue is practice of faith – it was never a problem, this land has produced Buddha, Jain, Guru Nanak, Sai baba’s and many more Babas, Peers and 1000 other gods that people worship who have different path to achieve truth.

            But if the fight is for identity – then you are fighting a political battle seeking a different identity from the rest of India (I dont understand what makes you different from us and why would you want to think you are an arab or live in groups). Goto Any DNA exam and you will be proved that our identity and affliation is Indian and not some arab world. your identity is Indian – thats your history – that you own and are responsible for the wealth of knowledge and tradition this nation has produced. All of us have to negotiate and build good will. You being Hindu, Muslim or christian is secondary. We are of same Blood and hopefully every family would have mix of every thing in time to come.

            what the world is trying to achieve today of being secular – India has already achieved this where shivaites, vaishnovaites, buddhists, jains, pagans and later parsis, muslims and now christians joined it. This is a spritual land with thousands of gods. How a person to person relationship should be clearly written in Gita however, you would call it a religious book rather than see it as a intellectual work done by our forefathers. In a hindu setup – you would easily have a family with different faiths under one roof. Your craving for secular world has long been resolved. But your craving for separate identity and have a nation within a nation is what RSS and BJP is against.

            If you really think we are all one, we must be secular then why have different laws for each religion? is human rights abuse not same for all? how can an abuse be different for muslims and hindus – this is nothing but preventing legal systems to function. Think of people who told you they would protect you as a muslim – which itself translates to a irritation to others and attract hate, on a second note have they really protected. Only 5% of muslims get into parliament and same percentage in govt jobs. Seek protection as a citizen of this country and human being. We as a nation should have one law and our religion has nothing todo with govt. Grow with talent and the more you try to play religion card the few will get their benefits but the most are going to suffer. We dont expect you to vote us but eventually when you understand the truth and practicality of reason and negotiation, I am sure you will come our way.

          • BLACKSMITH

            Honestly sir, you are an idiot no different than author of the above-mentioned letter.
            First of all, I am not from a minority religion of India, your direct consideration of me to it only shows your narrowminded outlook whereby you believe that a certain group is against you whilst the truth is other way round.
            There are many learned muslims with r.s.s. just as many learned hindus were with Jinnah. For the sake of power not realising what the divide will bring to the future.
            You have not answered what are the publications of hinduraashtra.
            i would just ask you to explain what gets published in your papers &articles.
            For any ignorant illiterate “blinded by sense of belonging to artificial cause”, i would want them to convince themselves that these people are good.
            Now before you Give another stupid theory full of lies , Take a look at the truth at blindness of saffron thyself
            https://www.facebook.com/saffronhindurashtra, their corelated page is:-
            https://www.facebook.com/refine.muslims
            now, let me remind you back, i was here to tell you that the author of the letter is narrowminded , he doesnt really support education, calling unbiased education (secular/neutral &true) as satanaic, but trying to write it politely so people dont find it offensive, the same is done to mass indians who fall for the trap of idiots like you. Honestly , I am not intrested in hearing your lies, for i knpw the truth, & i wont tell how racist -casteist &neo-fascist the articles of your groups have been, Only As Long As You Dont Reply to My Comments with your lies. If you wish to write more, make sure it has an explanation to my questions, if not, then keep your “belief” to yourself
            Back to the topic. Any one saying their religion’s teaching is the true education is a narrowminded superstitious idiot and &as well not a supporter of education (or woman/human rights or anything as such).

          • BLACKSMITH

            Girl, I told you not to comment to me unless you haved an explanation.
            You not-so dear kid, is very unclear about your side. You dint provide an explanation to prove right, you are speaking against other than to protect yourself, just providing excuse, on one hand you start of by saying we are all equal, on the other hand when i show you that the publishers of Saffron wing dont believe in it (in their own aarticles spreading hatred) , You try preaching history. YOu simply have no answer, and when you do realise that you were wrong, my job is done. I will repeat the author of the letter is narrowminded victim of culture who believes he is doing good (while he quotes “we support education/ secular education is satanic/only our religious teaching will save”) while being racist/casteist/un-equal biased human, & the saffron wing does the same, I would not fall for trap of any of such narrowminded (either ignorant-victim or cunningly using fallacies-on-cultural-grounds) irrespective of what religion or place they come from.
            Dont reply to me unless you overcome the blindness of “sense-of belonging , &protecting an irrational biased group”.

          • BLACKSMITH

            And that you accept human laws should be same for all, I appreciate , so cheers.
            Now that cant be achieved as long as people show themselves as religious before being human (esp with idiots religious fundies &apostasies against other religions while mocking apostates against self, in example idiots like taliban, public speaking idiots like Zakir Naik, political groups based on religion including indian saffron wings).
            For your kind information , I am an atheist, no religion &still a human.
            //Read the above message as well before you try preaching me or excusing a religious fundamentalist group//

          • mskhickory

            Since 1947, Muslims population has grown in India percentage wise – populations grow when the conditions are good.

            Secondly since you raised the point of the writer of this letter – he claims he can kill Malala not because of education but because she speaks against talibans.

            who gives them the right to do so? For the ones supporting this man, the writer lost it in the second paragraph. We should ask for a society that talk freely even the most contradictory debates – if we allow people to speak freely, then there is room for negotiation & debate and request you guys to not even give chance to people in weapons. There should be a dialogue even with RSS and dont treat them as your enemy instead negotiate….there cannot be a dialogue with killers though.

    • Humza Tariq

      shhh. its ok. ya little twat.

    • Mohsin Ali

      none of the things are happening in India which you have quoted in your comment ,this is the false belief and media is spreading these rumours.

    • jaz

      yooo fuck you you bastard. Its only because u hindus have small penis that ur ladies are sucking Muslim and christian cocks

    • Ishtiaq

      I think you didnt read the history… The muslim are the one who make the india as golden sparrow and bring prosperity in india. Before you hindus were divided into caste. No one can enjoy the liberty and no one was free. It all about muslims struggle and development that TAJ MAHAL is giving millions of dollars to the indian economy. Muslim ruled over india for centuries. Muslims were the rulers of india and ruled india with pride. If you have any comment come with proof.

  • Uzma Chaudhary

    same old story!!!

    • Toad Nunna

      Hmmmmmm………….a message bought by who?

  • ammar

    bloody fake letter

  • ammar

    PAKISTAN ARMY IS BESTTTT IN THE WORLD…THIS LETTER IS FAKE ANY PROOOF ?? HUH

    • murtaza

      well it is the truth as the army and FC always captures govt schools to use it for their barracks.
      I belong to that area so i know.

    • takichi

      pakistani army is a religion.. you are its worshipper

  • Uzma Chaudhary

    same old story!!!

  • habib

    “You have said in your speech yesterday that pen is mightier than sword, so they attacked you for your sword not for your books or school.”

    Did you people misinterpret this line? What sword does she have ??? none. She uses her pen. Her words. Her image as a beacon of hope. The Taliban abuse Islam to remain in power like local warlords. Basically he says they shot her because she said something bad about Islam. Taliban are nothing without power. A bunch of circleje rkers with no women to degrade. They keep their control with these orchestrated shootings. Malala tells the world of her life and they try to shut her up. Then they masquerade the effort as a fight for Islam. This isn’t about Islam, but this letter presupposes the plight of devout Muslim readers eagerly willing to further their faith. I am saddened to see the Facebook comments of those ego bought into it.

  • Kumail

    This letter is fake and God Bless Pakistan Army who are sending these American agents to the dept of Hell… Screw the writer

  • Qalb E Abbas

    Even if this letter is right, it is a crap, this person is trying to
    justify the attack on MALALA, where as whatever the reason is, it
    doesn’t justify attack on any HUMAN, who is breathing, and not harming
    anyone, Islam was not spread by Violence but by the character of
    Muhammad Peace Be Upon Him. If Taliban are character less people, then
    they really need sword and gun powder to spread their views, (it is
    their view of Islam, Not the real soul of Islam) Islam is not associated
    with Taliban views, If everyone else is killing innocent people, it
    doesn’t justify killing of Taliban. They are also killing Children and
    Women, who are not even raising weapons against them. No blody reason
    can justify their KILLINGS.

  • Guest

    Even if this letter is right, it is a crap, this person is trying to
    justify the attack on MALALA, where as whatever the reason is, it
    doesn’t justify attack on any HUMAN, who is breathing, and not harming
    anyone, Islam was not spread by Violence but by the character of
    Muhammad Peace Be Upon Him. If Taliban are character less people, then
    they really need sword and gun powder to spread their views, (it is
    their view of Islam, Not the real soul of Islam) Islam is not associated
    with Taliban views, If everyone else is killing innocent people, it
    doesn’t justify killing of Taliban. They are also killing Children and
    Women, who are not even raising weapons against them. No blody reason
    can justify their KILLINGS.

  • Sikandar Aziz

    Don’t know what to say..! On the one hand letter depicted some genuine issues of our Muslims he was truly right about American aggression,he said it right that if Malala had been killed by American drone,there was none to give him any title.
    But it also over exaggerated the terms so called Jewish Lobby for modern education or free masons for Syed Ahmed… Qur’an at many places has insisted to explore the world and Allah’s creations and it is only possible by exploration of modern knowledge. By the way the nib pen he may have used to right this letter was invented by a man of English in opinion, English in morale #Samuel Pepys. and the internet which is a global instrument and he used it to publish letter was invented by a Hindu in belief and American in taste #Shiva Ayyadurai

    • mskhickory

      problem I see with you guys is – we muslims, we christians….as if you guys are all different from us….why cant you just be individual and underplay that part….i dont get the desperation ot be affliated as a group?

  • Swaty Jewellery

    I firmly beleive in ‘Live and let live’,it does not matter whether you are a Christian, Muslim or Hindu. I am a Hindu but have close friends in all religions because it does not matter to me and I don’t understand why Christians should learn Quran or Muslims learn Bible. Everyone has the right to practice where they belief lies and not compelled because of birth or where they live and so on. I don’t think that Bible, Quran or Bhagawadgita or any other preachings would preach people to kill or harm others and the rest I beleive is well played politics( man-made) by people who think they have the power in their own hands and can do anything. When a natural calamity or accident occurs and you have a chance to save someone do you think whether he is a Muslim ,Christian or Hindu before lending a hand. I dont understand why does a man has to kill another man who gave him that right ?

    • Toad Nunna

      This is so wrong my siblings

      ,This is a tactic to divide and conquer,Could we be so concerned about religions as opposed to humanity………There is a higher agenda call it Illuminati or New Word order or what ever you want…They have you insulting and carrying out your ethnic pride while the NWO is fucking making steps and leaps EVERYDAY!!!!!…AND they have us in derision with each other due to the underhanded evil stuff THEY incite!!,We ALL know what evil is

      .I was born where I was born and I love people because I’m human.I implore you to unite against this government deception..NO NWO,We are becoming slaves to them while preoccupied by the violence THEY create…

      God help us all, no matter what you want to call him where you were born,color or ethnicity.PEACE, love, hope and prayers siblings.

  • zain ul abidin

    simply you can not judge any body on the basis of rumors ….walk a mile in the shoe of other then you came to know the truth…
    for both the Taliban supporter & anti-Taliban supporter .
    what your eye capture is not always the true picture….its only your perspective.

  • Kaisar

    To all those dumbwits who are still buying US drama of Muslims being the terrorists. Heres Zbigniew Brzezinski (US statesman who provoked and conspired USSR through CIA to invade Afghanistan in mid 70’s) reply to question asked in mid 1998, stated ‘If Islam is threat to peace to the modern world?’

    His answer: Nonsense! It is said that the West had a global policy in regard to Islam. That is stupid. There isn’t a global Islam. Look at Islam in a rational manner and without demagoguery or emotion. It is the leading religion of the world with 1.5 billion followers. But what is there in common among Saudi Arabian fundamentalism, moderate Morocco, Pakistan militarism, Egyptian pro-Western or Central Asian secularism? Nothing more than what unites the Christian countries.

  • Puja Patel

    People who die by drone attacks are collateral damage. Innocent Civilians die due to war. But the taliban are targeting a 15 year old girl. They have a 15 year old girl on their hit list. I dont think we can compare the two. Taliban are cowards.

    • http://dnasir.com/ Dzulqarnain Nasir

      I’m sorry but I disagree. There is no difference between “collateral damage” and “hit list”. Even if you didn’t intend to hurt anyone else but your target, attacking from a drone is just as cowardly as attacking a 15-year old.

      • Puja Patel

        sure. both need to be condemned. both parties are cowards.

  • D85

    There are many ways to mislead. I think that ALL government and religious leaders (with very few if any exceptions) seek to mislead the people who follow them. WHY is it that throughout history religious leaders have called for violence? I’m sure the people these so called leaders represent would rather not lose family members to war or strife. WE AS PEOPLE must stop allowing government and religious leaders to allow us to be tainted by their power-hungry wars.

    True strength is not knowing when to fight or kill, but knowing when not to.

    Peace and love to all of you.

  • TruthSpeaker

    Hindu scriptures worship ONE God. So how come there are fake numerous gods that are being worshipped? Rats, Cows and their dung and piss. Come back to ISLAM please.

  • TruthSpeaker

    Malala is getting too much air time and publicity. Who cares! Lets Go Red Sox!

  • TruthSpeaker

    Without Muslim Bollywood SRK, Salman, Aamir, there would be NO INDIA!

  • TruthSpeaker

    VEER ZARA movie. You see that? Feels Good Movie.

  • TruthSpeaker

    Malalala Shaklacka Barack Whaka has a UNIBROW. Sexay!

  • TruthSpeaker

    I love Indians who work at Subway, they don’t listen, I said TWO tomatoes, not THREE, Get it Rrrrright!

  • TruthSpeaker

    Jaya Prada, Sridevi..love their Hindu aura.

  • TruthSpeaker

    THA THAYA THA THAYA OH. EVER SEEN THAT JEETENDRA AND SRIDEVI SONG? WOW. SEXY SONG

  • Taha

    After reading a lot of hate comments from the same country people where she belongs to (and by the way I also belong to the same country) I am feeling like there some kind of campaign against her from their own people and I just don’t understand why. Do these people are supporters of Taliban who killed thousand of Innocent human beings and now claiming to be angels. What disappoint me more is the weak memories of the people of my country. They are easy to forget anything if you tell them it’s in the name of God. Their minds are so easy to manipulate and by the way that’s also because of less education.

    It’s possible they are might be the supporters of wahabis created by Saudi funding. Every one knows they are the main source of fundamentalist Islam. Taliban talks about book of Islam where as they have no clue about it. The only thing they know is hatred and violence and the funny thing is they do it by using the same technology whose eduction they are against of. Why most of the Talibans are pashtons because the violence is part of their culture.

    I don’t see any connection with the drones attacks and Malala. Don’t support her but support education. I believe if you get a proper education then you might be able to stand against drone attacks rather then wasting time on Facebook and social media. For me it just shows how ignorant and stupid we have become as a nation.

    • Rizwan

      Why most of the Talibans are pashtons because the violence is part of their culture.???? So u think we pashtoons are terrorists????

    • Humza Tariq

      shew. god. pakistan is in the gutter. This is what we have. People like you who just think whatever your friends or family tell you is 100% fact. “violence is part of a pathans culture?” fucking imbecile.

      • Taha

        Well you are fucking ignorant. I didn’t mean they are terrorist it just part of their culture. That’s what we have seen so far. The biggest illegal gun market is in your areas. Your dispute go on for ages and after killing many of each other. You sell drugs. You can’t event follow Islam properly. The only thing that you are good is at giving birth to children. What you want to believe us then? I know there are many educated and sensible pushtonos but certainly you are not one of them if you are.

  • Amir Khan

    I m holding my comments till Malala show courage to reply this letter with authentic justifications

    • mskhickory

      she should reply to a guy who thinks he can kill her because she is criticizing them, go get some schooling and stop being a victim for life?

  • Umar Ehsan

    truth shall be unfold… (y)…buck up who so ever is the actual writer…he indeed, speaks the truth.. !!!

  • Anupriya Kukreja

    False interpretation of the holy Quran or for that matter any religious book is the reason why our society has become so fake. All religions teach peace in the end. So why do the believers become dogmatic in their beliefs and start arguing? It’s all about ego and power these days. They just use ‘religion’ to feel powerful and important. And that’s exactly what the Taliban does. But the point about the “peaceful Americans” killing millions did make enough sense to conclude that America isn’t the innocent doll either. They’re just honey coated “killing for peace”. May real peace lovers win in the end. Amen

    • mskhickory

      so true, somehow the goal of religion has become to expand and grow vs enlighten and peace. we are finding ways to differentiate ourselves rather than unite.

  • Jibriil Mohamed

    God knows the best but according to my own personal view it seems that malala is used as tool to justify the evil acts of killing innocent civilians and drone attacks in muslim countries and she is looking to get fame and appear in the world stage media this letter clearly points out something we never thought before

  • Aayushi Gupta

    I think the reason why people are so OMGMINDBLOWN with the letter is because they can finally see what exactly drives these people. Does it really change things though? Most, if not all, of the letter is a unhealthy mixture of paranoia, hatred and misogyny. And misinformation. India was *rich* under the Mughal rule, and that translates to the fact that the kings were rich, not the people.

    Education, for another, is a dynamic field. Restricting a specific type of education isn’t really progressive on anyone’s part. The very fact that you have to use force to ensure people enroll in your system of education speaks volumes about the quality.

    You don’t, or rather, a legitimate entity doesn’t kill people because people made a wrong choice.

    And much of the propaganda in the letter is just bollocks. I sincerely don’t understand why people give so much importance to the views of the western world. THEY don’t think Rachael Carrie deserves her own holiday, you can’t force them to. Do YOU believe that every human who has been a victim of injustice should be valued the same? If you do, celebrate her. No one’s stopping you.

    But at the end of the day you are responsible for your own actions. Yes, the ‘developed world’ has its own lens of viewing things and yes, so does the Islam world, but I can’t understand how this justifies the attempted killing.

    THIS is a good attempt. This is civil. The shooting was not. And when people refuse to speak up against the shooting because they *understand* why someone did that, that sets the society decades back.

    If the Taliban wants to be viewed as a humane organization, they need to put down their guns and pick up a pen.

    Stop killing because people make choices.

  • Pete Taylor

    fighting isn’t peaceful, so fighting for peace is a lie! if it worked it would have made a difference by now. but it doesn’t. and that’s why nothing has got any better. history repeats itself for one reason only. people keep bringing up the past and keep continuing the same worn out drama. and nothing ever changes for the better because of it. Britain and America have ruined countless cultures trying to mold the world to the way they view things. and that’s lead to unspeakable and horrific incidences in the “past”. but then these things have occurred all over. islamic nations aren’t guilt free and have serious blood on their hands also. but then again neither is any other religion, political system or country free from these things either. a culture doesn’t make itself. people make a culture. so when other cultures force themselves onto others in any kind of way its oppression. and it works both ways. there’s a diversity in nature and a diversity in human expression for a reason. and that’s because its needed and both are free to express themselves in that way. no culture, religion or political system has got the harmony right to work alongside nature and god(if you believe in that) or is free from the need to change for the better. because if they had they would still be here now with no issues. but they haven’t. and that’s why they’ve either stumbled and fallen or are now showing serious cracks in their make up. people need to start waking up the fact that we are all in the same situation and the only way to solve the issue is to agree to disagree and work on actually making the effort to have peace. anything less than that wont work. and anything else with more to it than that probably has some kind of agenda. it should be peace for peace’s sake. because no peace ever came from war. apart from the fact it only points out the need for peace and the horror war brings! religion, cultures, and empires rise and fall. and they will continue to do so in horrific ways unless people really buck their ideas up and start working to create peace and harmony in a “peaceful way”. any other way is just bullshit and not only has never worked. but by the shear logics of it wont ever in the future. it is what it is! :)

  • annie

    malala u have a lot to learn…research the topics he has enlightened you with…Unfortunately a lot of what he says is true. You are still a child, and susceptible to the brainwashing tactics out there. You want to educate yourself, so research… and research… the history of Palestine and what the British and the rest of the so called G nations have done over the years to manipulate governments around the word including the Saudies. Seems to me this letter will guide you to many areas that will be an eye opener to you. Do not let the west manipulate you….Good Luck..

  • Omar Alansari-Kreger

    For every persuasion there is always something that can counter it. We are living in a world where
    we arbitrarily flock to what the mainstream institutions sell to us under a collectivized inclination that they share our common interests. It never usually dawns on us that just maybe they are working to sell us some sort of agenda even though the individual prompt in question is enshrined in a humanitarian triumph over atrocity. The cacophony of the world is further undermined when we fail to read the writing on the wall.

    Although Malala’s story is one that represents a triumph for third world justice and literacy, it must also be realized that the same person is being used as a poster child for an ideological call to persuasion. Bigger picture wise, what is the United Nations prepared to do when faced with the prospect of helping those who suffer beneath yokes of anti-intellectual cultures that internally suppress their own people? Furthermore, what does Malala plan to do with all of the publicity that she has managed to secure for herself?

    Maybe it should be implied that with great fame comes great responsibility considering that the former is an equivocal element of power.

  • Shahnawaz Alam

    let see what Malala has to say in defence.
    If she is truthful, she will reply.

  • Pokerface2501

    United we stand. Divided we fall. Pls all take a deep breath and stop hating. We nvr know whatever we hate the most will someday somehow help us. Be careful of what you say as it might hurt others.

  • disqus_s57IFJ4nnJ

    At least now I know there are members of the Taliban who just as good with BS as any US government agency or UN. Both sides are just as guilty when it comes to pulling wool over their supporters’ eyes.

  • mskhickory

    “Taliban believe that you were intentionally writing against them and running a smearing campaign to malign their efforts to establish Islamic system in swat and your writings were provocative” – so they got a right to kill a child because she is critizing. And see the gals and boys supporting the writer of this letter…..shameless. Cant these guys see what they have done to girl education in afghanisthan? A culture that is stagnant is dead – culture and knowledge grows from time to time….only rogues would support such letter…

  • africanoDj

    Stop killing one another, as simple as that…who are you to decide to kill another human being? why don’t you leave it to Allah/God whatever your belief is??? a simple yet strong “no” to violance….

  • sranumay

    Everyone plz dont give a fuck about religion,move ur lazy asses and start learning something.No one should say are useless, u should be worth something.Thats how we are gonna live in the world not with this bullshit religions.

  • Pawan

    Why you put Islam most sared then other beliefs which were prevailing before British came to India. What about Indian education system prior to Mughals came to India?

  • Syed Sayyar Badshah

    The Hidden truth <3

  • darth_vader

    genocide in kashmir?? who has done that?? Indian army or the muslims exterminating kashmiri pundits. Such a bunch of lies this letter carries. These misinformed spoiled brains result in more such crappy brains.

  • sachin

    i am quoting some of your lines mr. taliban and replying.

    “Taliban want to implement what is in the book of ALLAH and UNO want to implement what they have in man-made books.” –

    mr. taliban commander, please know one thing that when god created all humans, then what’s wrong in reading the man made books. just stop forcing your rules on the world which you are doing for a century. and i tell you that you will never be successful.

    “I wish the same for followers of Buddha to stop killing of innocent unarmed Muslims in Burma, and Sri Lanka and wish the same for Indian army to follow Gandhi jee and stop genocide in Kashmir” –

    Do you think only Muslims are innocent in this whole world. everyone else has no brains or what?

    Please don’t forget that islam has been spread on the verge of sword. so that proves you are the most violent religion and you should be stopped.

    Buddhist are the most peaceful people in the world and if in some corner of the world, a muslim is killed by a buddhist, then it is sure that there must have been some troubles created by the muslims first.

    You think genocide of muslims is happening in kashmir. Now i tell you before 600 or 700 years kashmir was dominated by hindus, now hindus are only 30% in kashmir. what did ‘peaceful innocent’ muslims do with Hindus there, you don’t know? Hindus were killed by muslims there just becoz they did not want to adopt your islamic satanic views. pakistan and afganistan where your base is today, that is infact the land of Hindus. If Hindus also go mad like you and take weapon to throw you out from this land then where will you go? Please don’t forget we Indians(Bharatwasi) treated muslims like a guest, when they came from somewere from middle east, and they looted India. But it is our religion that teaches us to maintain peace and believe in all faiths, which is why you are breathing easily sitting in the swat or pakistan.

    so please mind your tongue if you connect India with muslim education system. India education system is in its sanatan hindu culture.

    Does islam teach you to become human bomb. man how dumb and ridiculous this is?

    so my humble request to you is please stop modifying the views of mohammed just for your personal and political gains.

    • Shahzad

      “mr. taliban commander, please know one thing that when god created all humans, then what’s wrong in reading the man made books. just stop forcing your rules on the world which you are doing for a century. and i tell you that you will never be successful.”

      Yes god created all humans so humans should read his book, QURAN. Nobody forced islam over hindus, they welcomed it with opened arms, when the first muslim came to the indian subcontinent. The hindus were sick and tired of being oppresed by they hindu cast system and there ruler/dictators like Raja Dahir.

      “Buddhist are the most peaceful people in the world and if in some corner of the world, a muslim is killed by a buddhist, then it is sure that there must have been some troubles created by the muslims first.”

      You dumbass ignorant piece of shit, The genocide on muslims in Burma has been going on way before you were even born, by your peace loving ugly looking midget budists.

      GET YOUR FACTS RIGHT !!!!!!!!!!!!

      “If Hindus also go mad like you and take weapon to throw you out from this land then where will you go?”

      Yeah right we all know about you hindus courage, how brave you are, HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, don’t fool yourself.

      • sachin

        great wow.. height of illusions-
        – Hindus welcomed islam with open arms. woww
        – muslims came here and gave us civilization. woww
        – some comment about Hindu courage.

        Do you know why muslims are targeted worldwild. because you don’t possess little tolerance and acknowledgement about others faith. we welcomed you just becoz you were a guest from a foreign country, but that doesn’t mean we will forget our own culture for your retarded faith.
        for your comment about Hindu courage – prithiraj chauhan defetead muhammad gori 17 times, but one mistake he did that he did not kill him. if he killed him, then you would never have got entry in India(today’s india+pakistan). but it is mercy and forgiveness which is there in our blood, which made muhammad gori and several others take advantage.
        but please you don’t think that we will allow you now to fulfill all your satanic desires.

        tell me why did you have to kill people to make them convert to islam, becoz you all are satanic and now wipeout of your kind of extremists is important.

        pity on you that muhammad tried but failed to give true lessons of god to you and then how you modified his teachings according to your own personal and political gains.
        you retarded mind just understand one thing that god, allah, bhagwan all are the different names of same entity.
        so stop killing people in the name of god. because god is within everybody not just in you retarded mind

        • Shahzad

          Islam is an integral part of Indian subcontinent and its history. As the Indian subcontinent remains today a multi-ethnic and multi-religious place, it’s important to understand the position Islam has in the region.

          • sachin

            Islam has made position but by killing all non islamics. no wonder if your forefathers were also killed by islamic extremists.

      • sachin

        great wow height of illusions-

        – Hindus welcomed islam with open arms. woww

        – muslims came here and gave us civilization. woww

        – you know about Hindu courage.

        Do you know why muslims are targeted worldwild. because you don’t possess little tolerance and acknowledgement about others faith. we welcomed you just becoz you were a guest from a foreign country, but that doesn’t mean we will forget our own culture for your retarded faith.

        for your comment about Hindu courage – prithiraj chauhan defetead muhammad gori 17 times, but one mistake he did that he did not kill him. if he killed him, then you would never have got entry in India(today’s india+pakistan). but it is mercy and forgiveness which is there in our blood, which made muhammad gori and several others take advantage.

        but please you don’t think that we will allow you now to fulfill all your satanic desires.

        tell me why did you have to kill people to make them convert to islam, becoz you all are satanic and now wipeout of your kind of extremists is important.

        pity on you that muhammad tried but failed to give true lessons of god to you and then how you modified his teachings according to your own personal and political gains.

        you retarded mind just understand one thing that god, allah, bhagwan all are the different names of same entity.

        so stop killing people in the name of god. because god is within everybody not just in you retarded mind

        • Shahzad

          Let me tell you one thing, that us muslim from pak and india, we were hindus back in the days and most of us have been all the time from this soil. Our forefathers accepted islam because of its truth. We don’t kill people to convert them, it’s prohibited in islam to convert people by sword !!!!

          Pre-Islamic India was entirely based on a caste system in which society was broken into separate parts, conversion to Islam happened in a step-by-step process. Often, entire castes would convert to Islam at a time. This would happen for many different reasons. Often, however, the equality Islam provided was more attractive than the caste system’s organized racism. In the caste system, who you are born to determines your position in society. There was no opportunity for social mobility or to achieve greater than
          what your parents achieved. By converting to Islam, people had the opportunity to move up in society, and no longer were subservient to the Brahman caste.

          ”so stop killing people in the name of god”

          Why don’t you stop killing muslims in Assam region and Kashmir !!!

          You are talking about killing this and that, what about muslim killings in Bihar, Nellie, Mumbai, Gujarat etc. !!! Do you really think that muslims will be tolerating all your senseless killings !!!! Forget about it !!!

  • tolperon topedi

    Yeh Christians have churches, Muslims have mosques. One can always find peace inside them. Now hindus have temples, and those are the most dirty and noisy places with dhak and dhol chaos with the ugliest rituals ever found on earth. How can that be a peace-loving religion? Remove them from the world.

  • Sule

    Well what i feel is, NWO, Tailban all are same shit, just toilet is different, no one is fighting for anyone, They all are misled by fake propaganda’s which base can not be understood, Every common citizen just want to live peacefully, but these are nations who want war and are playing the game of dirty politics and propagandas.

  • Nawaz Khan

    80% of hindu population speaks volumes about the secular credentials of muslims and their tolerance towards other religions…during their invasion and 1000 years of governance…

  • Rudolf Sidhu

    Wars shall continue…no matter whether we want or not, coz ideological differences shall separate men from men, and women from women…

  • Hamdan Parvani

    Just One Question!

    Who was the first Human on this Planet?? Does anyone know??

  • arjumand

    m confused,if talib want peace then what about those people who are killed in markets,masajids,churchs,etc….is islam teaching this?????

    • poetman

      Islam does not teach violence and speaks against violence unless it is self defense.

      This Taliban leader quotes Gandhi and Jesus (as a prophet too), so obviously he does not condone attacking churches.

  • Pingback: Silencing Malala Yousafzai and “the Brown Man’s Honor Complex” | Meriam Sabih

  • Pingback: A Reply to: Malala Yousafzai and the White Saviour Complex | Media Diversity UK

  • Pingback: The unknown Malala | The Top Information Post

  • Hussain J Bello

    Illuminati all through your body………………….you have to be so cautious that you don’t sell your soul to the devils…Unawares!

  • Pingback: Politics, politics, politics | Dancing through life

  • Pingback: Silencing Malala Yousafzai and the Brown Man’s “Honor Complex” | Alternative News Alert!

  • Pingback: A Reply to: Malala Yousafzai and the White Saviour Complex | Media Diversified

  • Pingback: Silencing Malala Yousafzai and “the Brown Man’s Honour Complex” | The Lifting the Veil Project

  • Pingback: Silencing Malala Yousafzai and the Brown Man’s Honor Complex | The Lifting the Veil Project

  • Pingback: Silencing Malala Yousafzai and the brown man’s honor complex | altM

  • Ali

    It is right waht is written in letter to malala but the other side is alsot true that taliban is killing people in the name of other sects, mosques have been mdae killer places is it US or Pak army doing it. Who is brutely killing peopl in Syria an Iraq in the name of islam?

  • abhimanyu sharma

    If development, innovation, high standard of living is preached in New world order, then we should support it. This man wants women to stay in veils, cook food for men and bear children. These people do not care about society at all. They just believe in spreading terror, showing that they are supreme soldiers sent by god. If they have a god I believe God’s message is to save life not lay it in vain in his name. If they are worried about america bombing swat, why not teach the kids of swat science. Train them to build a superior technology, build better bombs and become capable to defend themselves. But they won’t since madarsas cannot teach good science. Good enough to make them developed and increase their standard of living. They know that women if learned will give them strong competition which these wimps are afraid of or may be just cannot accept. This letter is a display of their outdated thinking nothing else. Malala has hurt their egos and this is the only thing they can do since she has protection now. Only people they can shoot are unarmed and weak. Good work malala, you must have been sent by god himself to teach them a lesson.